Hybrid vs LPG?? Nonsence!

New direct injection diesels, hybrid electric motors, veg oil.. how do they compare to Autogas/LPG?
Posts: 12
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2008 5:56 pm
LPG System: STAG 300

Hybrid vs LPG?? Nonsence!

Postby SebastianS » Sat Oct 18, 2008 1:04 pm

Hi everybody!

A few words about comparing two ways to get your car more economical and more environment friendly:

As we know, hybrid systems include both - internal combustion engine, and electric one, to perform using possibly smallest amount of petrol fuel. Electrical engine is used to drive the car, using current stored in battery pack, which is recharged, when acceleration pedal is released, and brakes work. At this time electrical engine works "in opposite direction" - as generator, giving energy recovery directed to batteries.
On low and middle speeds, when need for power is relatively low, main source of driving power is electrical engine. When You need full power - both engines work together, giving the car maximum torque.
On every stop (crosslights etc) petrol engine stops, saving fuel and world :) Start is realised with electric one, working to start the car and additionally (when such need exist) as a starter motor for petrol one.

Now we can list characteristic parameters of hybrid system:

    - Main heart of system is still internal combustion engine as long, as You have to "fill up" the car with any form of energy, and we do not include charging batteries in home socket ;)
    - Due to fact, that combustion engine stops and starts very often (especially in city traffic) - it rather must not be diesel, which expects more stabile engine temperature to work properly, and starts usually with using of glowing plugs
    - Internal combustion engine works periodically, not all the time
    - Internal combustion engine is usually made with most modern (and most "green" technologies), what means often direct gasoline injection - to combustion chamber instead of inlet manifold.
    - Hybrid cars are unreasonably expensive due to complicated powering construction

Now let's have a look for LPG conversion:
We use to do it for only one reason: LPG fuel is (and always will be) much more cheap, than gasoline, and cost of conversion isn't high too. Additionally - burning LPG beats burning gasoline from environmental point of view. There's no problem to gain results of 30-40% of maximum EURO-4 amounts of toxic substances in exhaust gases when driving on LPG.

Now my question:
Why the hell somebody wants to compare alternative fueling system for petrol engine, with hybrid system, with heart being in fact the same petrol engine??

From technical point of view, there's no any problem for hybrid system to use LPG fuel for powering combustion engine in it. The only thing to solve is overcoming tech problem of using LPG in direct injected motors, but world-leading LPG companies are very close to offer fully tested solutions of such system.

So - if you really want to be more green, than Joschka Fischer (yers ago...) and Rainbow Warrior (years ago too...) together, you can arrange LPG conversion in your hybrid car to get most modern, most trendy, most expensive, heaviest and unpractical vehicle :D


Mark Jones
Posts: 56
Joined: Tue Aug 28, 2007 11:23 pm

Re: Hybrid vs LPG?? Nonsence!

Postby Mark Jones » Mon Oct 20, 2008 8:27 pm

The people who drive around in electric hybrids only think they are being kind to the environment

they are trendy ..and think its the done thing .

they are rolling in money ...........and can afford to buy a new car every couple of years .

The hybrid will save them nothing in the way of money ...because they are the sort who will be buying another car in two years time ....so what savings they make will be lost when they upgrade to another .

i pity the chap who buys one of these hybrids after them ............after two years the troubles will begin ........mega expensive batteries will have to be replaced ..........all these fancy regenerative brakes and electronic gimmickry after a couple of years of our winterly salt laden roads will be toast.

mind you .......when the price of LPG .equals only 30 pence lower that petrol .........thats it Ive finished with LPG.

the next car............thats if there is a next car ............will be a 1970s points ignition jobby.

i say ..if there is a next car .................because i fear the future .............

read in the paper the other day ...that average speed cameras are planned for every road in Britain.

i cant enjoy driving or be a safe driver if I'm looking at the speedo all the time.

bullocks to 'em all ..........they can shove their cars up their arises, if above comes about.

all the best.markj

Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Dec 05, 2017 10:05 am
LPG System: no
Car: no

Re: Hybrid vs LPG?? Nonsence!

Postby Burrola_12 » Tue Dec 12, 2017 10:01 am

The most environment friendly option though, would be electric cars as of now. The electric approach is not that popular, but is a great alternate to the vehicles that are running on natural resources. To get one, you can check out Electric car Buyers guide and save your part.

Return to “LPG v Diesel v Hybrid v Other”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest